16 Party-Ready Recipes for the Holidays

December 10, 2015 |

This post may contain affiliate links. Read about my affiliate policy.

16-Best-Holiday-Party-RecipesI only throw two parties a year. That may come as a shock to some of you given my obsession with food and entertaining, but it’s true.

Just to be clear, when I say “parties,” I don’t mean dinners and weird football gatherings. I’m talking about parties with a capital “P”—soirées that require significant planning (TG for Logan’s love of calendar reminders), enough food and booze to sedate a small army, and multiple strategies for avoiding eviction (the downstairs neighbors are not fans of our celebrations). These much anticipated annual events are Logena Christmas and Cinco de Mayo in honor of my two favorite non-birthday holidays, and I look forward to them like Logan looks forward to BBQ Fest. They’re the best.

Unfortunately, Logena Christmas has been canceled this year due to The Dude Diet’s somewhat painful New Year’s Eve deadline, but I’ve still found myself daydreaming about holiday party menus on the reg. And since I’m sure many of you have festive plans up your sleeves for the next few weeks, I thought I’d share some of my favorite bites, treats, and adult beverages for your merrymaking pleasure/inspiration.

Pour out some mulled wine for me…

Domesticate ME!’s Favorite Holiday Party Recipes:

beef-tenderloin-crostini-with-whipped-goat-cheese-and-pesto-20Beef Tenderloin Crostini with Whipped Goat Cheese and Pesto. This is hands-down my favorite appetizer recipe ever, holiday-themed or otherwise. I really want to say something profound about these magical bites, but for some reason I keep picturing Buddy the Elf screaming “You smell like beef and cheese!” (Probably because that’s an accurate description of me after assembling a tray of these bad boys.)

Brie-and-Candied-Bacon-Grilled-Cheese-Bites-5 (1 of 1)Brie and Candied Bacon Grilled Cheese BitesI don’t trust people that don’t like grilled cheese. Or bacon. You shouldn’t either. (Just kidding, vegetarian/vegan friends! Sort of.) p.s. Go all out and use a triple crème Brie. You won’t regret it…

easy-vegan-edamame-dip-4Easy Edamame DipThis trendy alternative to hummus is an excellent make-ahead option for more casual soirées. Just set it out with an array of fresh veggies and crackers and let people do da dip. (It also happens to be vegan and gluten-free, so everyone but the paleo peeps will be very excited!)

slow-roasted-beef-tenderloin-with-rosemary-10Slow-Roasted Beef Tenderloin with RosemaryFirst of all, this is the juiciest, most absurdly tender beef you will ever taste. (Thanks, Ina!) I know a full beef tenderloin isn’t standard finger food fare, but hear me out. If you slice the tenderloin very thin and set it out next to some good cheeses, sliced baguettes and a little mustard, pesto or aoli, people can assemble teeny tiny tenderloin sandwiches! Trust me, it will go over well.

Sweet-Potato-Hummus-Tartine-with-Toasted-Brussels-Sprouts-and-Goat-Cheese-8Sweet Potato Hummus Tartine with Toasted Brussels Sprouts and Goat CheeseSlice these tartines crosswise into “fingers,” or make bite-size versions on crackers or toasted slices of baguette.

Manchengo-crisps-with-serrano-ham-quince-paste-and-marcona-almondsManchengo Crisps with Serrano Ham, Quince and Marcona AlmondsMaking manchengo crisps is delightfully simple. Just sprinkle rounds of grated cheese on a parchment lined baking sheet and bake until browned. It’s so easy, yet the delicate cheesy snowflakes look wonderfully impressive, especially once you get all the fancy toppings involved.

Roasted-Butternut-Squash-Quesadillas-with-Goat-Cheese-and-Crispy-Sage-3Roasted Butternut Squash Quesadillas with Goat Cheese and Crispy Sage. Classy quesadillas are an excellent addition to any holiday fiesta. I recommend assembling them in advance and cooking them just as your guests start to arrive. (There’s nothing quite like greeting guests with something warm and cheesy in hand.)

Bacon-and-smoked-cheddar-stuffed-cheeseburger-sliders-with-jalapeno-relish-3Bacon and Smoked Cheddar Stuffed Cheeseburger Sliders with Jalapeño RelishI imagine everyone at your party will have this reaction to these mini burgers.

white-chocolate-peppermint-brownie-cookies-2Peppermint White Chocolate BrookiesIn the market for a slightly non-traditional Christmas cookie? This hybrid brownie-cookie gets my vote.

Holiday-Peppermint-Bark-Rice-Krispie-Treats-2Peppermint Bark Rice Krispie TreatsIf your baking skills leave something to be desired (no judgment), these treats are right up your alley. They take all of 20 minutes to assemble, and you never even have to turn on ze oven. Hallelujah!

peppermint-chocolate-chip-blondie-bites-10Peppermint Chocolate Chip Blondie BitesI know I’m not the only one with a seasonal peppermint fetish…

Chocolate-Chip-Cheesecake-Swirl-Brownie-BitesChocolate Chip Cheesecake-Swirl Brownie Bites. A friend described these bites as “super fudgy black bottom cupcakes.” Couldn’t have said it better myself.

easy-mulled-wine-the-best-holiday-cocktail-3Mulled WineNot only is mulled wine uber cozy and comforting, it will make your home smell like a warmly spiced holiday wonderland. Everyone wants to attend a party in a warmly spiced holiday wonderland. (Duh.)

grapefruit-rosemary-moscow-mule-cocktail-20Grapefruit Rosemary MuleI served these mules at Logena Christmas 2k14, and they were a raging success. With that said, if you wish to make them en masse, make sure you squeeze the grapefruit juice in advance. I gave some particularly sticky hugs last year.

Spiced-Cider-Bourbon-Punch-5Spiced Cider Bourbon PunchGo conservative by mixing up a batch of this party-ready punch with regular spiced apple cider, or turn things up with a hard cider. The choice is yours…

blood-orange-champagne-punch-2Blood Orange Champagne Punch.  It’s not Christmas without champagne. Pop some bottles and celebrate, friends!

Shop this post

Never miss a post!

Get new recipes and lifestyle tips delivered straight to your inbox.


  1. Taylor on December 10, 2015 at 11:54 am

    The sounds my friends have made upon my telling them of “Brie & Candied Bacon Grilled Cheese Bites” and “Beef Tenderloin Crostini with Whipped Goat Cheese & Pesto” makes me very confident that I’ve chosen the correct appetizers.

    Tis the season for compliments and borderline-NSFW sounds of appreciation.

  2. Kate on December 10, 2015 at 10:24 am

    Looks like that beef tenderloin is going to be making its way into my future parties! Better start channeling your inner Olivia Pope to handle that deadline!

Leave a Comment